{
 "schema": "delphi-ledger-feed/v1",
 "ledgers": [
  {
   "id": "outcomes",
   "title": "Delphi outcome ledger",
   "issue": 1487,
   "kind": "snapshot-comments",
   "semantics": "per-surface EWMA of graded signal weights (-1..+1), alpha=0.2 (ops/delphi/panel.json flywheel.ewma_alpha), damped: one EWMA step per batch at the batch mean (gate.py apply_outcomes, issue #1533); idempotency digest sha256(key|outcome)[:16] per surface, newest 2000 kept (gate.py signal_digest/dedupe_signals); tribute ingestion cap 200 records/batch (gate dispatch cap, PR #1824)",
   "derivation": null,
   "state_rule": "newest marker comment carrying a ```json block is the current state (gate.py latest_json)",
   "events": [
    {
     "event_key": "9a7b518fc24594565849dfa6518ce8a529426fb4b761ef6e9e9e7c14208f4820",
     "comment_id": 6321225375,
     "created_at": "2026-10-21T16:37:35Z",
     "marker": "<!-- delphi-outcomes v1 -->",
     "class": "machine-state",
     "headline": "1 signal(s): `tribute-lane` question_to_us +0.0",
     "payload": {
      "surfaces": {
       "tribute-lane": {
        "n": 1,
        "sum": 0.0,
        "ewma": 0.0,
        "by_outcome": {
         "question_to_us": 1
        },
        "repos": {
         "timerloggedout-spec/termux-monorepo": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": 0.0,
          "last": "question_to_us"
         }
        }
       }
      }
     }
    },
    {
     "event_key": "462590b3536038b55cd359db18ef8f7295ed493b8d99d2019ef1a885e620818f",
     "comment_id": 6442324046,
     "created_at": "2026-10-27T12:51:10Z",
     "marker": null,
     "class": "record",
     "headline": "[MUSEai]@{role:{delphi-lane}} \u2014 **correction to the Strands ballot + calibration appends above (comments 6437672193 / 6437672608), append-only.**",
     "payload": null
    },
    {
     "event_key": "6c8ecdd8d2f91847ce0583ebd29c2326c62a913cc079e5dea98c46c8d40b608d",
     "comment_id": 6444849082,
     "created_at": "2026-10-27T14:37:36Z",
     "marker": "<!-- delphi-outcomes v1 -->",
     "class": "machine-state",
     "headline": "State migration (2026-10-27, [MUSEai]@{role:{delphi-lane}}): the #1533 ingestion's first run posted the 169-signal backfill state to #1567 \u2014 the gate resolved its outcomes ledger by label order, and #",
     "payload": {
      "surfaces": {
       "tribute-lane": {
        "n": 170,
        "sum": -76.0,
        "ewma": -0.0899,
        "by_outcome": {
         "claimed_by_other": 64,
         "closed_already_assigned": 31,
         "low_effort_placeholder": 57,
         "needs_human_skill": 4,
         "merged": 11,
         "hostile_spam_flag": 2,
         "question_to_us": 1
        },
        "repos": {
         "0xLizTech/stellarforge": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.06,
          "last": "claimed_by_other"
         },
         "Agora-Events/agora": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.14,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "ApexChainx/ApexChainx-Contracts": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.14,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "C-Address-Onboarding-Bridge/C-Address-Onboarding-Bridge--Frontend-": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.11,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "C-Address-Onboarding-Bridge/C-Address-Onboarding-Bridge-Backend": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.14,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "CodeGirlsInc/FrieghtFlow": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.14,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "CopilotKit/CopilotKit": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.11,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "Dfunder/stellarAid-api": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.11,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "DioNanos/codex-termux": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.08,
          "last": "needs_human_skill"
         },
         "EF-CHAIN/SendAm": {
          "n": 3,
          "ewma": -0.0933,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "FasterThanAi/ai-lead-generation-mvp": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.06,
          "last": "claimed_by_other"
         },
         "GRITui/pixel-builder": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": 0.2,
          "last": "merged"
         },
         "Gautam-aman/ResQNet": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.09,
          "last": "closed_already_assigned"
         },
         "GlassHaven/Haven": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.2,
          "last": "hostile_spam_flag"
         },
         "Health-watchers/health_watchers": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.14,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "Heliobond/frontend": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.14,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "Hugelidus/Pointcast": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.16,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "KayStcx/KayStcx": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.11,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "LabsCrypt/remitlend": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.16,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "LandSandBoat/server": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.16,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "LaurierCS/locah-ai": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.12,
          "last": "closed_already_assigned"
         },
         "Lee-Dongwook/E2E-Self-Heal": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.06,
          "last": "claimed_by_other"
         },
         "LibreUML/LibreUML": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.16,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "Loment-Lang/Loment": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.16,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "MMALI3287/vibewatt": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.16,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "Magiclovekorean/unbloarchy": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.16,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "MergeFi/contracts": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.06,
          "last": "claimed_by_other"
         },
         "MyFanss/MyFans": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.14,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "Nano-Collective/nanocoder": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.12,
          "last": "closed_already_assigned"
         },
         "Neziahtech/streampay": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": 0.07,
          "last": "merged"
         },
         "Nodal-stellar/Nodal-AI": {
          "n": 4,
          "ewma": -0.01,
          "last": "claimed_by_other"
         },
         "NousResearch/hermes-agent": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.08,
          "last": "needs_human_skill"
         },
         "O2sa/DevImpact": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.14,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "OBLIQ-in/OBLIQ-Website": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.16,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "Octo-Protocol-org/Octo-frontend": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": 0.04,
          "last": "merged"
         },
         "P-r-e-m-i-u-m/open-source-starter-lab": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": 0.2,
          "last": "merged"
         },
         "ROCm/rocm-libraries": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.06,
          "last": "claimed_by_other"
         },
         "RetinaX-Org/RetinaX": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.06,
          "last": "claimed_by_other"
         },
         "SO4-Markets/interface": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.06,
          "last": "claimed_by_other"
         },
         "SO4-Markets/so4-oracle": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.14,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "Saidur-droid/MergeEarn": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.06,
          "last": "claimed_by_other"
         },
         "ShippedLabs/soroban-upgrade-safeguard": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.06,
          "last": "claimed_by_other"
         },
         "Soneso/stellar-agent-wallet": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.16,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "SoroScan/soroscan": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.11,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "Stellar-songifi/Lyricsflip_server": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.14,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "StellarCanary/Protocol-Canary": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.06,
          "last": "claimed_by_other"
         },
         "StellarFoundry/soroban-security-scanner": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.06,
          "last": "claimed_by_other"
         },
         "StellarLock/StellarLock": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.14,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "Suhas29wasnotavailable/blroad": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.16,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "TabularisDB/tabularis": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.16,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "ThinkLikeAFounder/pulsartrack": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.14,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "TricklePay/tricklepay-backend": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.14,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "TrusTrove/TrusTrove-contract": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.06,
          "last": "claimed_by_other"
         },
         "TrustHire/hiresettle-backend": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.11,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "UnityChainxx/StellarHunts": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": 0.07,
          "last": "merged"
         },
         "Vikram-sardiwal/react-open-source": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": 0.07,
          "last": "merged"
         },
         "Wayfare-labs/wayfare": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.11,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "aHuddini/UniPlaySong": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.16,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "adharshramu12/Seetha_ai": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.16,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "amponce/archive-movie-browser": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.06,
          "last": "claimed_by_other"
         },
         "anomalyco/opencode": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.12,
          "last": "closed_already_assigned"
         },
         "apache/hugegraph-computer": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.16,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "arsova-mx/OpenPoker": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.16,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "bmad-code-org/bmad-loop": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.06,
          "last": "claimed_by_other"
         },
         "ciaren-labs/Ciaren": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.16,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "cubrid-lab/cubrid-mcp-server": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.16,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "dentalpin/dentalpin": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.16,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "dereksantos/cortex": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.16,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "ennouaimi/invoicr": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.06,
          "last": "claimed_by_other"
         },
         "estruyf/playwright-github-actions-reporter": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.16,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "finos/fluxnova-bpm-platform": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.16,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "francordel/kdemos": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.08,
          "last": "needs_human_skill"
         },
         "fsr5-fhaachen/portals": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.16,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "gabe-santana/saccade": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": 0.2,
          "last": "merged"
         },
         "infagent/merl": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.12,
          "last": "closed_already_assigned"
         },
         "inferstep/ATLAS": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.14,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "kawacukennedy/afrpoweros": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.06,
          "last": "claimed_by_other"
         },
         "kiinshuk/kinshow": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.09,
          "last": "closed_already_assigned"
         },
         "laugh-tales/starpass-contracts": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.06,
          "last": "claimed_by_other"
         },
         "limelit-co/open": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.06,
          "last": "claimed_by_other"
         },
         "lonestill/scope-launcher": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.09,
          "last": "closed_already_assigned"
         },
         "marrabld/omazone": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.16,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "mergepay/mergepay-web": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": 0.04,
          "last": "merged"
         },
         "nesstyx/ChessHome": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.16,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "nextcloud/spreed": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.16,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "prime-radiant-inc/evener": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.16,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "pulseaiclub/phi": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.16,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "pyrite-wiki/pyrite": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.2,
          "last": "hostile_spam_flag"
         },
         "qim-center/qim3d": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.14,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "rishiyaduwanshi/boiler": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.16,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "seleniumboot/selenium-boot": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.06,
          "last": "claimed_by_other"
         },
         "shadcn-labs/ogimagecn": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.06,
          "last": "claimed_by_other"
         },
         "sorolens/sorolens": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.06,
          "last": "claimed_by_other"
         },
         "sorotrail/SoroTrail": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": 0.04,
          "last": "merged"
         },
         "speedyk-005/yasbd-lib": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.14,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "ssupportme/support-me": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.06,
          "last": "claimed_by_other"
         },
         "stellar-compliance-kit/compliance-primitives": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.11,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "tarantool/tarantool": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.16,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "topoteretes/cognee": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.06,
          "last": "claimed_by_other"
         },
         "traceopt-ai/traceml": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.06,
          "last": "claimed_by_other"
         },
         "tusharmotwani1718/dropsend": {
          "n": 2,
          "ewma": -0.14,
          "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
         },
         "use-assay/Assay": {
          "n": 4,
          "ewma": -0.1,
          "last": "claimed_by_other"
         },
         "ussyalfaks/ahjoorxmr-contract": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": -0.12,
          "last": "closed_already_assigned"
         },
         "uttrflow/uttrflow-swift": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": 0.2,
          "last": "merged"
         },
         "timerloggedout-spec/termux-monorepo": {
          "n": 1,
          "ewma": 0.0,
          "last": "question_to_us"
         }
        }
       }
      },
      "digests": {
       "tribute-lane": [
        "9c915f8012db3eb1",
        "0523793f97e245de",
        "25ed95dbd9d7d2cd",
        "4c41c728d0621ee9",
        "9f2d3bd5c0352b4e",
        "8de464672d667423",
        "27c671b8aa8261cd",
        "999c1a06ae8c810f",
        "badb0296fd5a06f9",
        "bf969acd547dbbae",
        "cca64c0a1fc54a14",
        "8243706e08c8ab6e",
        "6c1f7037239d2850",
        "2c262a70402076de",
        "50cd026737303db0",
        "3818ef644c5f1af5",
        "eed14f6bb8dc2059",
        "8f3516a911477f70",
        "c4a9f2c289999dc7",
        "229865446b7373a7",
        "6ce190cdfdfcd2da",
        "81da3ac44d7b281c",
        "6f4c78eb5b491266",
        "f54f2af8780b9478",
        "10c28c7ab5b025f2",
        "0b276b8418acb788",
        "9fbddb77fb1cce1e",
        "a5eb123d31111a1c",
        "a9c97af7bd3e71eb",
        "3e2f93629b935201",
        "30384e147dd1543a",
        "790188fd99852609",
        "4d37053f6e8e5798",
        "a8c2a37c9d16ee9b",
        "3a4e390eb80ebbe9",
        "9b71c647fd9ab138",
        "4cb961b59ccb5595",
        "4d55ca495dc72ea3",
        "ce7e24ab0670c850",
        "36587eae6cb44bd9",
        "97774447f36f1128",
        "98f69ed35d4ce4fb",
        "55e919e68f4b6a4b",
        "cb6b23bda1921d6d",
        "7ef916965656dc0f",
        "81c5a4620ec38850",
        "5697c0310211b083",
        "dd5c7b249a64f21d",
        "86ecb5ea5dc673cd",
        "7ede8b4709e42782",
        "f5d6ce9377326c58",
        "8ee992175db5f1c7",
        "8e844878d5b855fe",
        "653384774dd3c7f7",
        "f5788f4a97c0fb66",
        "ee078e07e2227241",
        "2edba8210e5622a6",
        "dc4a2dde0a9fa330",
        "a9a2f00624fd74c3",
        "b1957835008a64bd",
        "5e820350b0d5e82d",
        "0be684de16b467be",
        "bcccc76daf7fdfd9",
        "10a59783a2fd4b61",
        "d4fc191f239597ae",
        "819060d723c8dacc",
        "3c4bf5f8fa8e8114",
        "90be9d4939a399f1",
        "aec0a4b7220b50c0",
        "78d6515eb42cfa1a",
        "87b62091a476c5b4",
        "3569b1c6fb2f33e7",
        "e76aac1e45dc7178",
        "b22acc967345f4e2",
        "214d9d062ea65245",
        "71d8976eedfaa826",
        "f005388d274501f2",
        "a153c01047720e2c",
        "65bf29f6b0affeb6",
        "85039c8f38cc09c7",
        "f4eefa6b16276e40",
        "d43fe743dcc682ee",
        "08a02b6c184c816e",
        "9036653a4178f306",
        "271c946e89ef261a",
        "b9420886b644a7d1",
        "99296f36387054f4",
        "4c2b945d8909cc20",
        "d1094098f5574d7f",
        "f6e32f2dae1651a3",
        "6a8df485235f51bb",
        "0cd5962a4ef639e3",
        "1aeff92b9b9d2dea",
        "b902d7211a661b4f",
        "c4da524ecf365fe4",
        "e52773bcd0d2227e",
        "46ed97d741d8753e",
        "3b05a4fdb8f1cccf",
        "5873da4a8550d5be",
        "dfc754e9937532cf",
        "e0e5b40ff2a579b6",
        "7e9d0d2abb7c893c",
        "7201cfe3e0fa0592",
        "d699fd8419456a2f",
        "ba311f5420a922d4",
        "ffa3905952a10378",
        "c69b44dd9f3fa7bd",
        "16e6570d4fb14cfe",
        "a2398398dbea964c",
        "1b77c3f8c99263ad",
        "67df38abf00b1a08",
        "8cb348a8ffa24ee5",
        "5838b96a43634f6f",
        "0ef53cc55507bde9",
        "482db7ed68721dbe",
        "7c28efc89a67834c",
        "525b0f9ecfe787d5",
        "d47e6e4361ef4f83",
        "9ba177713f054fc3",
        "5a1179cb8e909458",
        "10bfd1aef8774c25",
        "9118e026495383cf",
        "c08d05e3c215e025",
        "9a2a9d5abc51fb32",
        "523bd7dd2f65639c",
        "95d2f61876f4ba90",
        "49cd0f420210cf26",
        "86fbadc45aa0905d",
        "bc999b8395561a7f",
        "4ad9764ddd4a7d46",
        "4aef3228fc41232b",
        "15dc3e41b158ebff",
        "7aabf7ae8a4ee144",
        "cb6a7816f971595a",
        "f6e06bc2703e8cd1",
        "5c752934ddbcc4da",
        "88af87cef3e3860e",
        "ad0241d1a7eb836f",
        "538c6b0758020dd2",
        "dec1b0dcdc40122c",
        "2f4dcc59e9824034",
        "d64901238926cf2a",
        "175ad1f408d9d5a7",
        "c0632791760d07ff",
        "38f80d45f270f5ba",
        "cb5b1207d16a7dcd",
        "fabdddaa9ed2018f",
        "f7fae4547f84f2d7",
        "44ee162e1a3ca2f3",
        "7aadb984af49794a",
        "51e98f77f0599736",
        "0dae396ec72703d6",
        "97b0f74c7aab6fc2",
        "3cfff36aea2dac56",
        "b692edd6d5352b29",
        "8f19228bc0b437fe",
        "d02462dfb821fde4",
        "ebaa28755c61b8e8",
        "d965f4334c4b1530",
        "2e2ed3a4f4e336b3",
        "e696412da71de435",
        "183662cedf1026f1",
        "345d020c3e1f02a3",
        "e7963fbbdcafa217",
        "2e2d4e9361846ccf",
        "81f62cc69cce9d34",
        "427d4e119829de2b",
        "8f76bdb23a76d81d",
        "41cc52a7f82358ff"
       ]
      }
     }
    },
    {
     "event_key": "158133aae611c47975e3ddbd44b155c5ff676fd5b3f97a4e20469fd3c638abae",
     "comment_id": 6460260505,
     "created_at": "2026-10-28T03:56:11Z",
     "marker": null,
     "class": "record",
     "headline": "[MUSEai]@{role:{doe-expert}}",
     "payload": null
    },
    {
     "event_key": "d5cf4b58afd9a17197af0de840648b11789f289621b5c7032ce0aefe53e6bce2",
     "comment_id": 6463698580,
     "created_at": "2026-10-28T07:54:25Z",
     "marker": null,
     "class": "record",
     "headline": "[MUSEai]@{role:{delphi-validation}} \u2014 RECHECK FIX (owner ruling 2026-10-28: 30d park ridiculous). PR #1986 merged a365e1e5: panel award.research_recheck_days=2, gate award() applies it to research.* o",
     "payload": null
    },
    {
     "event_key": "3a5a645aef42d1ee6f4c512ffdef5c94dea27b5de4facaaf0ea8b8c3f99efc5c",
     "comment_id": 6469868202,
     "created_at": "2026-10-28T13:11:13Z",
     "marker": null,
     "class": "record",
     "headline": "[MUSEai]@{role:{doe-expert}}",
     "payload": null
    },
    {
     "event_key": "b37c2be689d412ecfbedb1915d8e4204dbe58509ca6f4e05962f22853e3cd65e",
     "comment_id": 6472613783,
     "created_at": "2026-10-28T15:05:52Z",
     "marker": null,
     "class": "record",
     "headline": "[MUSEai]@{role:{comment-quality}} \u2014 CENSUS + CLEANUP RECORD (2026-10-28, owner order via Delphi lane; noise definition = this registry ledger-feed definition, coordinated with Delphi lane + database l",
     "payload": null
    }
   ],
   "current": {
    "comment_id": 6444849082,
    "created_at": "2026-10-27T14:37:36Z",
    "payload": {
     "surfaces": {
      "tribute-lane": {
       "n": 170,
       "sum": -76.0,
       "ewma": -0.0899,
       "by_outcome": {
        "claimed_by_other": 64,
        "closed_already_assigned": 31,
        "low_effort_placeholder": 57,
        "needs_human_skill": 4,
        "merged": 11,
        "hostile_spam_flag": 2,
        "question_to_us": 1
       },
       "repos": {
        "0xLizTech/stellarforge": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.06,
         "last": "claimed_by_other"
        },
        "Agora-Events/agora": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.14,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "ApexChainx/ApexChainx-Contracts": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.14,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "C-Address-Onboarding-Bridge/C-Address-Onboarding-Bridge--Frontend-": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.11,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "C-Address-Onboarding-Bridge/C-Address-Onboarding-Bridge-Backend": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.14,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "CodeGirlsInc/FrieghtFlow": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.14,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "CopilotKit/CopilotKit": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.11,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "Dfunder/stellarAid-api": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.11,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "DioNanos/codex-termux": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.08,
         "last": "needs_human_skill"
        },
        "EF-CHAIN/SendAm": {
         "n": 3,
         "ewma": -0.0933,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "FasterThanAi/ai-lead-generation-mvp": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.06,
         "last": "claimed_by_other"
        },
        "GRITui/pixel-builder": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": 0.2,
         "last": "merged"
        },
        "Gautam-aman/ResQNet": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.09,
         "last": "closed_already_assigned"
        },
        "GlassHaven/Haven": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.2,
         "last": "hostile_spam_flag"
        },
        "Health-watchers/health_watchers": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.14,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "Heliobond/frontend": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.14,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "Hugelidus/Pointcast": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.16,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "KayStcx/KayStcx": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.11,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "LabsCrypt/remitlend": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.16,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "LandSandBoat/server": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.16,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "LaurierCS/locah-ai": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.12,
         "last": "closed_already_assigned"
        },
        "Lee-Dongwook/E2E-Self-Heal": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.06,
         "last": "claimed_by_other"
        },
        "LibreUML/LibreUML": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.16,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "Loment-Lang/Loment": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.16,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "MMALI3287/vibewatt": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.16,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "Magiclovekorean/unbloarchy": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.16,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "MergeFi/contracts": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.06,
         "last": "claimed_by_other"
        },
        "MyFanss/MyFans": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.14,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "Nano-Collective/nanocoder": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.12,
         "last": "closed_already_assigned"
        },
        "Neziahtech/streampay": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": 0.07,
         "last": "merged"
        },
        "Nodal-stellar/Nodal-AI": {
         "n": 4,
         "ewma": -0.01,
         "last": "claimed_by_other"
        },
        "NousResearch/hermes-agent": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.08,
         "last": "needs_human_skill"
        },
        "O2sa/DevImpact": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.14,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "OBLIQ-in/OBLIQ-Website": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.16,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "Octo-Protocol-org/Octo-frontend": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": 0.04,
         "last": "merged"
        },
        "P-r-e-m-i-u-m/open-source-starter-lab": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": 0.2,
         "last": "merged"
        },
        "ROCm/rocm-libraries": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.06,
         "last": "claimed_by_other"
        },
        "RetinaX-Org/RetinaX": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.06,
         "last": "claimed_by_other"
        },
        "SO4-Markets/interface": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.06,
         "last": "claimed_by_other"
        },
        "SO4-Markets/so4-oracle": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.14,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "Saidur-droid/MergeEarn": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.06,
         "last": "claimed_by_other"
        },
        "ShippedLabs/soroban-upgrade-safeguard": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.06,
         "last": "claimed_by_other"
        },
        "Soneso/stellar-agent-wallet": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.16,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "SoroScan/soroscan": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.11,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "Stellar-songifi/Lyricsflip_server": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.14,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "StellarCanary/Protocol-Canary": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.06,
         "last": "claimed_by_other"
        },
        "StellarFoundry/soroban-security-scanner": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.06,
         "last": "claimed_by_other"
        },
        "StellarLock/StellarLock": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.14,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "Suhas29wasnotavailable/blroad": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.16,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "TabularisDB/tabularis": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.16,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "ThinkLikeAFounder/pulsartrack": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.14,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "TricklePay/tricklepay-backend": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.14,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "TrusTrove/TrusTrove-contract": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.06,
         "last": "claimed_by_other"
        },
        "TrustHire/hiresettle-backend": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.11,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "UnityChainxx/StellarHunts": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": 0.07,
         "last": "merged"
        },
        "Vikram-sardiwal/react-open-source": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": 0.07,
         "last": "merged"
        },
        "Wayfare-labs/wayfare": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.11,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "aHuddini/UniPlaySong": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.16,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "adharshramu12/Seetha_ai": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.16,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "amponce/archive-movie-browser": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.06,
         "last": "claimed_by_other"
        },
        "anomalyco/opencode": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.12,
         "last": "closed_already_assigned"
        },
        "apache/hugegraph-computer": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.16,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "arsova-mx/OpenPoker": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.16,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "bmad-code-org/bmad-loop": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.06,
         "last": "claimed_by_other"
        },
        "ciaren-labs/Ciaren": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.16,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "cubrid-lab/cubrid-mcp-server": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.16,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "dentalpin/dentalpin": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.16,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "dereksantos/cortex": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.16,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "ennouaimi/invoicr": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.06,
         "last": "claimed_by_other"
        },
        "estruyf/playwright-github-actions-reporter": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.16,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "finos/fluxnova-bpm-platform": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.16,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "francordel/kdemos": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.08,
         "last": "needs_human_skill"
        },
        "fsr5-fhaachen/portals": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.16,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "gabe-santana/saccade": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": 0.2,
         "last": "merged"
        },
        "infagent/merl": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.12,
         "last": "closed_already_assigned"
        },
        "inferstep/ATLAS": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.14,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "kawacukennedy/afrpoweros": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.06,
         "last": "claimed_by_other"
        },
        "kiinshuk/kinshow": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.09,
         "last": "closed_already_assigned"
        },
        "laugh-tales/starpass-contracts": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.06,
         "last": "claimed_by_other"
        },
        "limelit-co/open": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.06,
         "last": "claimed_by_other"
        },
        "lonestill/scope-launcher": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.09,
         "last": "closed_already_assigned"
        },
        "marrabld/omazone": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.16,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "mergepay/mergepay-web": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": 0.04,
         "last": "merged"
        },
        "nesstyx/ChessHome": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.16,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "nextcloud/spreed": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.16,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "prime-radiant-inc/evener": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.16,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "pulseaiclub/phi": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.16,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "pyrite-wiki/pyrite": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.2,
         "last": "hostile_spam_flag"
        },
        "qim-center/qim3d": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.14,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "rishiyaduwanshi/boiler": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.16,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "seleniumboot/selenium-boot": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.06,
         "last": "claimed_by_other"
        },
        "shadcn-labs/ogimagecn": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.06,
         "last": "claimed_by_other"
        },
        "sorolens/sorolens": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.06,
         "last": "claimed_by_other"
        },
        "sorotrail/SoroTrail": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": 0.04,
         "last": "merged"
        },
        "speedyk-005/yasbd-lib": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.14,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "ssupportme/support-me": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.06,
         "last": "claimed_by_other"
        },
        "stellar-compliance-kit/compliance-primitives": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.11,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "tarantool/tarantool": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.16,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "topoteretes/cognee": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.06,
         "last": "claimed_by_other"
        },
        "traceopt-ai/traceml": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.06,
         "last": "claimed_by_other"
        },
        "tusharmotwani1718/dropsend": {
         "n": 2,
         "ewma": -0.14,
         "last": "low_effort_placeholder"
        },
        "use-assay/Assay": {
         "n": 4,
         "ewma": -0.1,
         "last": "claimed_by_other"
        },
        "ussyalfaks/ahjoorxmr-contract": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": -0.12,
         "last": "closed_already_assigned"
        },
        "uttrflow/uttrflow-swift": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": 0.2,
         "last": "merged"
        },
        "timerloggedout-spec/termux-monorepo": {
         "n": 1,
         "ewma": 0.0,
         "last": "question_to_us"
        }
       }
      }
     },
     "digests": {
      "tribute-lane": [
       "9c915f8012db3eb1",
       "0523793f97e245de",
       "25ed95dbd9d7d2cd",
       "4c41c728d0621ee9",
       "9f2d3bd5c0352b4e",
       "8de464672d667423",
       "27c671b8aa8261cd",
       "999c1a06ae8c810f",
       "badb0296fd5a06f9",
       "bf969acd547dbbae",
       "cca64c0a1fc54a14",
       "8243706e08c8ab6e",
       "6c1f7037239d2850",
       "2c262a70402076de",
       "50cd026737303db0",
       "3818ef644c5f1af5",
       "eed14f6bb8dc2059",
       "8f3516a911477f70",
       "c4a9f2c289999dc7",
       "229865446b7373a7",
       "6ce190cdfdfcd2da",
       "81da3ac44d7b281c",
       "6f4c78eb5b491266",
       "f54f2af8780b9478",
       "10c28c7ab5b025f2",
       "0b276b8418acb788",
       "9fbddb77fb1cce1e",
       "a5eb123d31111a1c",
       "a9c97af7bd3e71eb",
       "3e2f93629b935201",
       "30384e147dd1543a",
       "790188fd99852609",
       "4d37053f6e8e5798",
       "a8c2a37c9d16ee9b",
       "3a4e390eb80ebbe9",
       "9b71c647fd9ab138",
       "4cb961b59ccb5595",
       "4d55ca495dc72ea3",
       "ce7e24ab0670c850",
       "36587eae6cb44bd9",
       "97774447f36f1128",
       "98f69ed35d4ce4fb",
       "55e919e68f4b6a4b",
       "cb6b23bda1921d6d",
       "7ef916965656dc0f",
       "81c5a4620ec38850",
       "5697c0310211b083",
       "dd5c7b249a64f21d",
       "86ecb5ea5dc673cd",
       "7ede8b4709e42782",
       "f5d6ce9377326c58",
       "8ee992175db5f1c7",
       "8e844878d5b855fe",
       "653384774dd3c7f7",
       "f5788f4a97c0fb66",
       "ee078e07e2227241",
       "2edba8210e5622a6",
       "dc4a2dde0a9fa330",
       "a9a2f00624fd74c3",
       "b1957835008a64bd",
       "5e820350b0d5e82d",
       "0be684de16b467be",
       "bcccc76daf7fdfd9",
       "10a59783a2fd4b61",
       "d4fc191f239597ae",
       "819060d723c8dacc",
       "3c4bf5f8fa8e8114",
       "90be9d4939a399f1",
       "aec0a4b7220b50c0",
       "78d6515eb42cfa1a",
       "87b62091a476c5b4",
       "3569b1c6fb2f33e7",
       "e76aac1e45dc7178",
       "b22acc967345f4e2",
       "214d9d062ea65245",
       "71d8976eedfaa826",
       "f005388d274501f2",
       "a153c01047720e2c",
       "65bf29f6b0affeb6",
       "85039c8f38cc09c7",
       "f4eefa6b16276e40",
       "d43fe743dcc682ee",
       "08a02b6c184c816e",
       "9036653a4178f306",
       "271c946e89ef261a",
       "b9420886b644a7d1",
       "99296f36387054f4",
       "4c2b945d8909cc20",
       "d1094098f5574d7f",
       "f6e32f2dae1651a3",
       "6a8df485235f51bb",
       "0cd5962a4ef639e3",
       "1aeff92b9b9d2dea",
       "b902d7211a661b4f",
       "c4da524ecf365fe4",
       "e52773bcd0d2227e",
       "46ed97d741d8753e",
       "3b05a4fdb8f1cccf",
       "5873da4a8550d5be",
       "dfc754e9937532cf",
       "e0e5b40ff2a579b6",
       "7e9d0d2abb7c893c",
       "7201cfe3e0fa0592",
       "d699fd8419456a2f",
       "ba311f5420a922d4",
       "ffa3905952a10378",
       "c69b44dd9f3fa7bd",
       "16e6570d4fb14cfe",
       "a2398398dbea964c",
       "1b77c3f8c99263ad",
       "67df38abf00b1a08",
       "8cb348a8ffa24ee5",
       "5838b96a43634f6f",
       "0ef53cc55507bde9",
       "482db7ed68721dbe",
       "7c28efc89a67834c",
       "525b0f9ecfe787d5",
       "d47e6e4361ef4f83",
       "9ba177713f054fc3",
       "5a1179cb8e909458",
       "10bfd1aef8774c25",
       "9118e026495383cf",
       "c08d05e3c215e025",
       "9a2a9d5abc51fb32",
       "523bd7dd2f65639c",
       "95d2f61876f4ba90",
       "49cd0f420210cf26",
       "86fbadc45aa0905d",
       "bc999b8395561a7f",
       "4ad9764ddd4a7d46",
       "4aef3228fc41232b",
       "15dc3e41b158ebff",
       "7aabf7ae8a4ee144",
       "cb6a7816f971595a",
       "f6e06bc2703e8cd1",
       "5c752934ddbcc4da",
       "88af87cef3e3860e",
       "ad0241d1a7eb836f",
       "538c6b0758020dd2",
       "dec1b0dcdc40122c",
       "2f4dcc59e9824034",
       "d64901238926cf2a",
       "175ad1f408d9d5a7",
       "c0632791760d07ff",
       "38f80d45f270f5ba",
       "cb5b1207d16a7dcd",
       "fabdddaa9ed2018f",
       "f7fae4547f84f2d7",
       "44ee162e1a3ca2f3",
       "7aadb984af49794a",
       "51e98f77f0599736",
       "0dae396ec72703d6",
       "97b0f74c7aab6fc2",
       "3cfff36aea2dac56",
       "b692edd6d5352b29",
       "8f19228bc0b437fe",
       "d02462dfb821fde4",
       "ebaa28755c61b8e8",
       "d965f4334c4b1530",
       "2e2ed3a4f4e336b3",
       "e696412da71de435",
       "183662cedf1026f1",
       "345d020c3e1f02a3",
       "e7963fbbdcafa217",
       "2e2d4e9361846ccf",
       "81f62cc69cce9d34",
       "427d4e119829de2b",
       "8f76bdb23a76d81d",
       "41cc52a7f82358ff"
      ]
     }
    }
   },
   "excluded_noise": 1
  },
  {
   "id": "weights",
   "title": "Delphi panel weights ledger",
   "issue": 1489,
   "kind": "snapshot-comments",
   "semantics": "per-role gate_pass_rate EWMA (step = alpha*|weight|) + Elo (k=16, panel.json flywheel.elo_k), hits/misses tallies (gate.py feedback_graded)",
   "derivation": {
    "formula": "w_i = base_i * (0.5 + gate_pass_rate_i) * (elo_i / 1500)",
    "source": "docs/ops/DELPHI-WEIGHTING.md",
    "ewma_alpha": 0.2,
    "elo_k": 16,
    "rule": "weights are DERIVED from events by this formula \u2014 stores carry events + this derivation; snapshots are payloads of record, never the only copy of the math",
    "effective": "effective = sum(w_i * score_i) / sum(w_i)",
    "hit_rule": "hit = (role final vote >= shadow_min 15.0) == (outcome == 'confirmed')",
    "update": {
     "gate_pass_rate": "round(0.8*gpr + 0.2*(1 if hit else 0), 4)  [binary feedback, gate.feedback]",
     "elo": "round(elo + 16 if hit else elo - 16, 1)  [k=16]",
     "tallies": "hits/misses++ per graded outcome"
    },
    "cold_start": "ops/delphi/panel.json seeds (gpr 0.5, elo 1500, hits/misses 0)",
    "roles": {
     "OPERATOR": 1.2,
     "builder": 1.0,
     "reviewer": 1.0,
     "Scout": 0.8,
     "cost_auditor": 1.2
    }
   },
   "state_rule": "newest marker comment carrying a ```json block is the current state (gate.py latest_json)",
   "events": [
    {
     "event_key": "c7b48884904e2958780ba436352cc3a9ea0dd5169434f8ab4f6faed279d7fd43",
     "comment_id": 6321256851,
     "created_at": "2026-10-21T16:39:01Z",
     "marker": "<!-- delphi-weights v1 -->",
     "class": "machine-state",
     "headline": "Feedback from #1424: outcome **confirmed**",
     "payload": {
      "roles": {
       "OPERATOR": {
        "base": 1.2,
        "gate_pass_rate": 0.6,
        "elo": 1516,
        "hits": 1,
        "misses": 0
       },
       "builder": {
        "base": 1.0,
        "gate_pass_rate": 0.6,
        "elo": 1516,
        "hits": 1,
        "misses": 0
       },
       "reviewer": {
        "base": 1.0,
        "gate_pass_rate": 0.6,
        "elo": 1516,
        "hits": 1,
        "misses": 0
       },
       "Scout": {
        "base": 0.8,
        "gate_pass_rate": 0.6,
        "elo": 1516,
        "hits": 1,
        "misses": 0
       },
       "cost_auditor": {
        "base": 1.2,
        "gate_pass_rate": 0.6,
        "elo": 1516,
        "hits": 1,
        "misses": 0
       }
      }
     }
    },
    {
     "event_key": "33aab1cfb8257d5b83ad56a47c3a14e386889edc83df7dd5f353c5ea3cb5b800",
     "comment_id": 6321265454,
     "created_at": "2026-10-21T16:39:26Z",
     "marker": "<!-- delphi-weights v1 -->",
     "class": "machine-state",
     "headline": "Feedback from #1424: outcome **confirmed**",
     "payload": {
      "roles": {
       "OPERATOR": {
        "base": 1.2,
        "gate_pass_rate": 0.68,
        "elo": 1532,
        "hits": 2,
        "misses": 0
       },
       "builder": {
        "base": 1.0,
        "gate_pass_rate": 0.68,
        "elo": 1532,
        "hits": 2,
        "misses": 0
       },
       "reviewer": {
        "base": 1.0,
        "gate_pass_rate": 0.68,
        "elo": 1532,
        "hits": 2,
        "misses": 0
       },
       "Scout": {
        "base": 0.8,
        "gate_pass_rate": 0.68,
        "elo": 1532,
        "hits": 2,
        "misses": 0
       },
       "cost_auditor": {
        "base": 1.2,
        "gate_pass_rate": 0.68,
        "elo": 1532,
        "hits": 2,
        "misses": 0
       }
      }
     }
    },
    {
     "event_key": "d1bcb6fac2789020579369c37eee2ca6fdd174ff22def70bd3aa77a120c8f270",
     "comment_id": 6442654206,
     "created_at": "2026-10-27T13:07:37Z",
     "marker": null,
     "class": "record",
     "headline": "[MUSEai]@{role:{3l0-weighting-backfill}} \u2014 coordination note for the Delphi lane (owner of this ledger); no weights data in this comment, parsers unaffected.",
     "payload": null
    }
   ],
   "current": {
    "comment_id": 6321265454,
    "created_at": "2026-10-21T16:39:26Z",
    "payload": {
     "roles": {
      "OPERATOR": {
       "base": 1.2,
       "gate_pass_rate": 0.68,
       "elo": 1532,
       "hits": 2,
       "misses": 0
      },
      "builder": {
       "base": 1.0,
       "gate_pass_rate": 0.68,
       "elo": 1532,
       "hits": 2,
       "misses": 0
      },
      "reviewer": {
       "base": 1.0,
       "gate_pass_rate": 0.68,
       "elo": 1532,
       "hits": 2,
       "misses": 0
      },
      "Scout": {
       "base": 0.8,
       "gate_pass_rate": 0.68,
       "elo": 1532,
       "hits": 2,
       "misses": 0
      },
      "cost_auditor": {
       "base": 1.2,
       "gate_pass_rate": 0.68,
       "elo": 1532,
       "hits": 2,
       "misses": 0
      }
     }
    }
   },
   "excluded_noise": 2
  },
  {
   "id": "generation",
   "title": "Delphi generation ballots + calibrations (appended to the outcome ledger issue)",
   "issue": 1487,
   "kind": "event-comments",
   "semantics": "append-only; a later signed [MUSEai]@ comment may correct an earlier event (corrections are new events, never edits)",
   "derivation": null,
   "state_rule": "no folded state; the event stream is the record (ranked outcomes + calibration deltas feeding weights/outcomes)",
   "events": [
    {
     "event_key": "3b78b81dbffff518ba546734ee0668330d8504f8d9f4ac959c48d5ff9046549f",
     "comment_id": 6437672193,
     "created_at": "2026-10-27T08:56:15Z",
     "marker": "<!-- delphi-generation-ballot v1 -->",
     "class": "machine-state",
     "headline": "[MUSEai]@{role:{delphi-lane}} \u2014 first LIVE Oracle Method pass: ranked outcome.",
     "payload": {
      "pass_id": "strands-rfp-response",
      "record": "docs/proposals/passes/strands-rfp-response/",
      "round_1": {
       "ranked_outcome": [
        "strands-rfp-response-collection-first",
        "strands-rfp-response-kernel-first",
        "strands-rfp-response-packaging-first"
       ],
       "ballots_by_class": {
        "HUMAN_COLLABORATOR": 0,
        "MODEL_PROVIDER": 0,
        "LOCAL_BASELINE": 5
       },
       "classes_present": [
        "LOCAL_BASELINE"
       ],
       "classes_absent": [
        "HUMAN_COLLABORATOR",
        "MODEL_PROVIDER"
       ]
      },
      "round_2": {
       "ranked_outcome": [
        "strands-rfp-response-collection-first",
        "strands-rfp-response-kernel-first",
        "strands-rfp-response-packaging-first"
       ],
       "evidence_set_sha256": "620b67b3eee6a70bb4c290d944a76e1bef2597788fc8c5cdd8d39e9000ba6c48",
       "ballots_by_class": {
        "HUMAN_COLLABORATOR": 0,
        "MODEL_PROVIDER": 0,
        "LOCAL_BASELINE": 5
       }
      },
      "specified_not_run": {
       "aws_deployment_ITEMS-007": "card rule",
       "model_panel_ITEMS-006": "DELPHI_LLM_MAX=0"
      }
     }
    },
    {
     "event_key": "2e2830dcae9cce05350d71a2ca4a5d73c566b4066c3090cfe49070c4b3d70f14",
     "comment_id": 6437672608,
     "created_at": "2026-10-27T08:56:16Z",
     "marker": "<!-- delphi-generation-calibration v1 -->",
     "class": "machine-state",
     "headline": "[MUSEai]@{role:{delphi-lane}} \u2014 calibration feed for the weighting/elo ledgers.",
     "payload": {
      "type": "delphi-generation-calibration",
      "pass_id": "strands-rfp-response",
      "calibration": {
       "schema": "oracle-method-calibration/v1",
       "evidence_set_sha256": "620b67b3eee6a70bb4c290d944a76e1bef2597788fc8c5cdd8d39e9000ba6c48",
       "candidates": {
        "LOCAL_BASELINE": {
         "strands-rfp-response-collection-first": {
          "expected_rank": 1,
          "actual_rank": 1,
          "rank_delta": 0,
          "expected_score": 23.269,
          "actual_score": 25.0,
          "score_delta": 1.731,
          "within_tolerance": true,
          "moved_on_evidence": [
           "full test pass in the implementation round"
          ]
         },
         "strands-rfp-response-kernel-first": {
          "expected_rank": 2,
          "actual_rank": 2,
          "rank_delta": 0,
          "expected_score": 23.269,
          "actual_score": 25.0,
          "score_delta": 1.731,
          "within_tolerance": true,
          "moved_on_evidence": [
           "full test pass in the implementation round"
          ]
         },
         "strands-rfp-response-packaging-first": {
          "expected_rank": 3,
          "actual_rank": 3,
          "rank_delta": 0,
          "expected_score": 23.269,
          "actual_score": 25.0,
          "score_delta": 1.731,
          "within_tolerance": true,
          "moved_on_evidence": [
           "full test pass in the implementation round"
          ]
         }
        },
        "BRIEF:delphi-lane": {
         "strands-rfp-response-collection-first": {
          "expected_rank": 2,
          "actual_rank": 1,
          "rank_delta": -1,
          "expected_score": 16,
          "actual_score": 25.0,
          "score_delta": 9.0,
          "within_tolerance": false,
          "moved_on_evidence": [
           "full test pass in the implementation round"
          ]
         },
         "strands-rfp-response-kernel-first": {
          "expected_rank": 1,
          "actual_rank": 2,
          "rank_delta": 1,
          "expected_score": 19,
          "actual_score": 25.0,
          "score_delta": 6.0,
          "within_tolerance": false,
          "moved_on_evidence": [
           "full test pass in the implementation round"
          ]
         },
         "strands-rfp-response-packaging-first": {
          "expected_rank": 3,
          "actual_rank": 3,
          "rank_delta": 0,
          "expected_score": 13,
          "actual_score": 25.0,
          "score_delta": 12.0,
          "within_tolerance": false,
          "moved_on_evidence": [
           "full test pass in the implementation round"
          ]
         }
        }
       }
      }
     }
    },
    {
     "event_key": "2b30cfe74a8d1743a88e477d09c264a2048ad384004845ab43693d39c23e37d8",
     "comment_id": 6458968877,
     "created_at": "2026-10-28T02:25:55Z",
     "marker": "<!-- delphi-generation-ballot v1 -->",
     "class": "machine-state",
     "headline": "[MUSEai]@{role:{delphi-lane}} \u2014 second LIVE Oracle Method pass: ranked outcome.",
     "payload": {
      "pass_id": "temporal-durable-execution",
      "record": "docs/proposals/passes/temporal-durable-execution/",
      "round_1": {
       "ranked_outcome": [
        "temporal-durable-execution-contract-first",
        "temporal-durable-execution-pi-core-resume",
        "temporal-durable-execution-serverless-skill",
        "temporal-durable-execution-versioned-autoscale",
        "temporal-durable-execution-cookbook-agent-loop"
       ],
       "note": "four-way tie at 23.654 (pi-core-resume, contract-first, serverless-skill, versioned-autoscale); cookbook-agent-loop 23.077; order among tied = alphabetical tie-break"
      },
      "round_2": {
       "ranked_outcome": [
        "temporal-durable-execution-contract-first",
        "temporal-durable-execution-cookbook-agent-loop",
        "temporal-durable-execution-pi-core-resume",
        "temporal-durable-execution-serverless-skill",
        "temporal-durable-execution-versioned-autoscale"
       ],
       "note": "four-way tie at 25.0 (all candidates whose declared suites passed); versioned-autoscale separated at 11.615 (omes suite unexecutable in the pass environment, zero under the phantom-test rule)"
      },
      "ballots_by_class": {
       "LOCAL_BASELINE": "rubric comparator (ledger weights from #1489)",
       "HUMAN_COLLABORATOR": 0,
       "MODEL_PROVIDER": 0
      },
      "moneyball_weighted": {
       "temporal-durable-execution-pi-core-resume": 8.9,
       "temporal-durable-execution-cookbook-agent-loop": 8.5,
       "temporal-durable-execution-contract-first": 6.5,
       "temporal-durable-execution-serverless-skill": 4.8,
       "temporal-durable-execution-versioned-autoscale": 3.6
      },
      "g6_disposition": {
       "temporal-durable-execution-pi-core-resume": "adopt",
       "temporal-durable-execution-cookbook-agent-loop": "pilot",
       "temporal-durable-execution-contract-first": "adopt (contract discipline)",
       "temporal-durable-execution-serverless-skill": "reference-only",
       "temporal-durable-execution-versioned-autoscale": "reference-only"
      }
     }
    },
    {
     "event_key": "d6a37243e31b93bfdfff98b8249233e4b2a2f866fd4790ea68388b8db5a0d424",
     "comment_id": 6458969136,
     "created_at": "2026-10-28T02:25:56Z",
     "marker": "<!-- delphi-generation-calibration v1 -->",
     "class": "machine-state",
     "headline": "[MUSEai]@{role:{delphi-lane}} \u2014 calibration feed for the weighting/elo ledgers (TD-005: posted to both ledgers).",
     "payload": {
      "type": "delphi-generation-calibration",
      "pass_id": "temporal-durable-execution",
      "calibration": {
       "schema": "oracle-method-calibration/v1",
       "evidence_set_sha256": "8d67dc0326925dac8ea739891d12d707cd92cb07ceb6d95f56c8cbda9291fd76",
       "candidates": {
        "LOCAL_BASELINE": {
         "temporal-durable-execution-contract-first": {
          "expected_rank": 1,
          "actual_rank": 1,
          "rank_delta": 0,
          "expected_score": 23.654,
          "actual_score": 25.0,
          "score_delta": 1.346,
          "within_tolerance": true,
          "moved_on_evidence": [
           "full test pass in the implementation round"
          ]
         },
         "temporal-durable-execution-cookbook-agent-loop": {
          "expected_rank": 5,
          "actual_rank": 2,
          "rank_delta": -3,
          "expected_score": 23.077,
          "actual_score": 25.0,
          "score_delta": 1.923,
          "within_tolerance": true,
          "moved_on_evidence": [
           "full test pass in the implementation round"
          ]
         },
         "temporal-durable-execution-pi-core-resume": {
          "expected_rank": 2,
          "actual_rank": 3,
          "rank_delta": 1,
          "expected_score": 23.654,
          "actual_score": 25.0,
          "score_delta": 1.346,
          "within_tolerance": true,
          "moved_on_evidence": [
           "full test pass in the implementation round"
          ]
         },
         "temporal-durable-execution-serverless-skill": {
          "expected_rank": 3,
          "actual_rank": 4,
          "rank_delta": 1,
          "expected_score": 23.654,
          "actual_score": 25.0,
          "score_delta": 1.346,
          "within_tolerance": true,
          "moved_on_evidence": [
           "full test pass in the implementation round"
          ]
         },
         "temporal-durable-execution-versioned-autoscale": {
          "expected_rank": 4,
          "actual_rank": 5,
          "rank_delta": 1,
          "expected_score": 23.654,
          "actual_score": 11.615,
          "score_delta": -12.039,
          "within_tolerance": false,
          "moved_on_evidence": [
           "1 failing test(s) in the implementation round"
          ]
         }
        },
        "BRIEF:BRIEF:temporal-recon-lane": {
         "temporal-durable-execution-contract-first": {
          "expected_rank": 3,
          "actual_rank": 1,
          "rank_delta": -2,
          "expected_score": 16,
          "actual_score": 25.0,
          "score_delta": 9.0,
          "within_tolerance": false,
          "moved_on_evidence": [
           "full test pass in the implementation round"
          ]
         },
         "temporal-durable-execution-cookbook-agent-loop": {
          "expected_rank": 2,
          "actual_rank": 2,
          "rank_delta": 0,
          "expected_score": 19,
          "actual_score": 25.0,
          "score_delta": 6.0,
          "within_tolerance": false,
          "moved_on_evidence": [
           "full test pass in the implementation round"
          ]
         },
         "temporal-durable-execution-pi-core-resume": {
          "expected_rank": 1,
          "actual_rank": 3,
          "rank_delta": 2,
          "expected_score": 22,
          "actual_score": 25.0,
          "score_delta": 3.0,
          "within_tolerance": false,
          "moved_on_evidence": [
           "full test pass in the implementation round"
          ]
         },
         "temporal-durable-execution-serverless-skill": {
          "expected_rank": 5,
          "actual_rank": 4,
          "rank_delta": -1,
          "expected_score": 10,
          "actual_score": 25.0,
          "score_delta": 15.0,
          "within_tolerance": false,
          "moved_on_evidence": [
           "full test pass in the implementation round"
          ]
         },
         "temporal-durable-execution-versioned-autoscale": {
          "expected_rank": 4,
          "actual_rank": 5,
          "rank_delta": 1,
          "expected_score": 13,
          "actual_score": 11.615,
          "score_delta": -1.385,
          "within_tolerance": true,
          "moved_on_evidence": [
           "1 failing test(s) in the implementation round"
          ]
         }
        }
       }
      }
     }
    },
    {
     "event_key": "34d9936cc0855275f34e198e5b1a7e7425500ebd93ae2791948c9f986d6c1066",
     "comment_id": 6459554998,
     "created_at": "2026-10-28T03:05:22Z",
     "marker": "<!-- delphi-research-silos v1 -->",
     "class": "machine-state",
     "headline": "[MUSEai]@{role:{delphi-lane}} \u2014 research-silo baseline comparison, first improve-cycle (post-hoc record per RESEARCH-SILO-DELPHI.md rules; no cross-silo aggregate score \u2014 attribution stays per silo).",
     "payload": null
    },
    {
     "event_key": "6466cf3e92d4006995ee87858310254286deb589deffbfad46fe5fe51857c557",
     "comment_id": 6478757703,
     "created_at": "2026-10-28T19:37:53Z",
     "marker": "<!-- delphi-generation-ballot v1 -->",
     "class": "machine-state",
     "headline": "<!-- n5-emit:delphi-cycle/rehearsal:ballot_round1 -->",
     "payload": {
      "type": "delphi-generation-ballot",
      "pass_id": "rehearsal",
      "round": 1,
      "ballot": {
       "schema": "delphi-cross-vote/v1",
       "generated_at": "2026-10-28T00:00:00Z",
       "candidates": [
        "rehearsal-strong",
        "rehearsal-weak",
        "rehearsal-empty"
       ],
       "profiles": [
        {
         "candidate": "rehearsal-strong",
         "dependency_items": 0,
         "docs_sha256": "429596243f40c5970d2e4414cb1dc8c12c063db0fd485768e7312594ce835708",
         "evidence_sources": 2,
         "evidenced": 2,
         "evidenced_ratio": 1.0,
         "items": 1,
         "money_veto": false,
         "points": 2,
         "unverified": 0
        },
        {
         "candidate": "rehearsal-weak",
         "dependency_items": 1,
         "docs_sha256": "71f5264e85b9f355c3675dd6305812f38d3d87df45d270023e3450c07e1e72e3",
         "evidence_sources": 2,
         "evidenced": 1,
         "evidenced_ratio": 0.5,
         "items": 2,
         "money_veto": true,
         "points": 2,
         "unverified": 1
        },
        {
         "candidate": "rehearsal-empty",
         "dependency_items": 0,
         "docs_sha256": "9100e8f2577d8a68ea377248c73d3c961e511de0c84c6ad7f6aa05b0ebc124f9",
         "evidence_sources": 2,
         "evidenced": 0,
         "evidenced_ratio": 0.0,
         "items": 1,
         "money_veto": false,
         "points": 1,
         "unverified": 1
        }
       ],
       "weights": {
        "source": "fixture panel (tests/test_delphi_cross_vote PANEL)",
        "role_weights": {
         "OPERATOR": 1.4462,
         "Scout": 0.9641,
         "builder": 1.2052,
         "cost_auditor": 1.4462,
         "reviewer": 1.2052
        }
       },
       "ballots": [
        {
         "voter": "rubric:OPERATOR",
         "source_class": "LOCAL_BASELINE",
         "scores": {
          "rehearsal-strong": 25,
          "rehearsal-weak": 12,
          "rehearsal-empty": 1
         },
         "rationale": {
          "rehearsal-strong": "evidenced_ratio 1.0 (2/2 points evidenced); unverified 0; items 1; evidence_sources 2; dependency_items 0",
          "rehearsal-weak": "evidenced_ratio 0.5 (1/2 points evidenced); unverified 1; items 2; evidence_sources 2; dependency_items 1; money veto applied (score capped at 4)",
          "rehearsal-empty": "evidenced_ratio 0.0 (0/1 points evidenced); unverified 1; items 1; evidence_sources 2; dependency_items 0"
         },
         "evidence_refs": [
          "generation profiles derived from each candidate's PROVENANCE evidence sets"
         ]
        },
        {
         "voter": "rubric:Scout",
         "source_class": "LOCAL_BASELINE",
         "scores": {
          "rehearsal-strong": 25,
          "rehearsal-weak": 19,
          "rehearsal-empty": 12
         },
         "rationale": {
          "rehearsal-strong": "evidenced_ratio 1.0 (2/2 points evidenced); unverified 0; items 1; evidence_sources 2; dependency_items 0",
          "rehearsal-weak": "evidenced_ratio 0.5 (1/2 points evidenced); unverified 1; items 2; evidence_sources 2; dependency_items 1; money veto applied (score capped at 4)",
          "rehearsal-empty": "evidenced_ratio 0.0 (0/1 points evidenced); unverified 1; items 1; evidence_sources 2; dependency_items 0"
         },
         "evidence_refs": [
          "generation profiles derived from each candidate's PROVENANCE evidence sets"
         ]
        },
        {
         "voter": "rubric:builder",
         "source_class": "LOCAL_BASELINE",
         "scores": {
          "rehearsal-strong": 21,
          "rehearsal-weak": 10,
          "rehearsal-empty": 8
         },
         "rationale": {
          "rehearsal-strong": "evidenced_ratio 1.0 (2/2 points evidenced); unverified 0; items 1; evidence_sources 2; dependency_items 0",
          "rehearsal-weak": "evidenced_ratio 0.5 (1/2 points evidenced); unverified 1; items 2; evidence_sources 2; dependency_items 1; money veto applied (score capped at 4)",
          "rehearsal-empty": "evidenced_ratio 0.0 (0/1 points evidenced); unverified 1; items 1; evidence_sources 2; dependency_items 0"
         },
         "evidence_refs": [
          "generation profiles derived from each candidate's PROVENANCE evidence sets"
         ]
        },
        {
         "voter": "rubric:cost_auditor",
         "source_class": "LOCAL_BASELINE",
         "scores": {
          "rehearsal-strong": 25,
          "rehearsal-weak": 4,
          "rehearsal-empty": 1
         },
         "rationale": {
          "rehearsal-strong": "evidenced_ratio 1.0 (2/2 points evidenced); unverified 0; items 1; evidence_sources 2; dependency_items 0",
          "rehearsal-weak": "evidenced_ratio 0.5 (1/2 points evidenced); unverified 1; items 2; evidence_sources 2; dependency_items 1; money veto applied (score capped at 4)",
          "rehearsal-empty": "evidenced_ratio 0.0 (0/1 points evidenced); unverified 1; items 1; evidence_sources 2; dependency_items 0"
         },
         "evidence_refs": [
          "generation profiles derived from each candidate's PROVENANCE evidence sets"
         ]
        },
        {
         "voter": "rubric:reviewer",
         "source_class": "LOCAL_BASELINE",
         "scores": {
          "rehearsal-strong": 25,
          "rehearsal-weak": 12,
          "rehearsal-empty": 1
         },
         "rationale": {
          "rehearsal-strong": "evidenced_ratio 1.0 (2/2 points evidenced); unverified 0; items 1; evidence_sources 2; dependency_items 0",
          "rehearsal-weak": "evidenced_ratio 0.5 (1/2 points evidenced); unverified 1; items 2; evidence_sources 2; dependency_items 1; money veto applied (score capped at 4)",
          "rehearsal-empty": "evidenced_ratio 0.0 (0/1 points evidenced); unverified 1; items 1; evidence_sources 2; dependency_items 0"
         },
         "evidence_refs": [
          "generation profiles derived from each candidate's PROVENANCE evidence sets"
         ]
        },
        {
         "evidence_refs": [
          "fixture evidence set a.claim/b.claim"
         ],
         "rationale": "strong is fully evidenced; weak rests one point on a missing claim; empty is unevidenced",
         "scores": {
          "rehearsal-empty": 6,
          "rehearsal-strong": 20,
          "rehearsal-weak": 12
         },
         "source_class": "HUMAN_COLLABORATOR",
         "voter": "registrar:owner"
        }
       ],
       "ballots_by_class": {
        "HUMAN_COLLABORATOR": 1,
        "MODEL_PROVIDER": 0,
        "LOCAL_BASELINE": 5
       },
       "per_class": {
        "HUMAN_COLLABORATOR": {
         "ballots": 1,
         "scores": {
          "rehearsal-empty": 6.0,
          "rehearsal-strong": 20.0,
          "rehearsal-weak": 12.0
         },
         "ranking": [
          "rehearsal-strong",
          "rehearsal-weak",
          "rehearsal-empty"
         ]
        },
        "MODEL_PROVIDER": {
         "ballots": 0,
         "scores": {},
         "ranking": []
        },
        "LOCAL_BASELINE": {
         "ballots": 5,
         "scores": {
          "rehearsal-strong": 24.231,
          "rehearsal-weak": 10.846,
          "rehearsal-empty": 4.038
         },
         "ranking": [
          "rehearsal-strong",
          "rehearsal-weak",
          "rehearsal-empty"
         ]
        }
       },
       "classes_present": [
        "HUMAN_COLLABORATOR",
        "LOCAL_BASELINE"
       ],
       "classes_absent": [
        "MODEL_PROVIDER"
       ],
       "combined_ranking": [
        "rehearsal-strong",
        "rehearsal-weak",
        "rehearsal-empty"
       ],
       "ranked_outcome": [
        "rehearsal-strong",
        "rehearsal-weak",
        "rehearsal-empty"
       ],
       "class_rule": "Source classes tallied and reported separately, never merged (DEBATE protocol). DRIVER_SYNTHESIS is not a ballot."
      }
     }
    },
    {
     "event_key": "40de5526a12bb6ed83e38a3034ae28f3b2d7d6b92d4f173245229f6ebda1abb4",
     "comment_id": 6478758831,
     "created_at": "2026-10-28T19:37:56Z",
     "marker": "<!-- delphi-generation-ballot v1 -->",
     "class": "machine-state",
     "headline": "<!-- n5-emit:delphi-cycle/rehearsal:ballot_round2 -->",
     "payload": {
      "type": "delphi-generation-ballot",
      "pass_id": "rehearsal",
      "round": 2,
      "ballot": {
       "schema": "delphi-cross-vote/v1",
       "round": 2,
       "evidence_set_sha256": "dde5aac5d62b8e6f6a946564908ee055b3e19cc488c61aeee62015013768d9ac",
       "ballots_by_class": {
        "HUMAN_COLLABORATOR": 1,
        "MODEL_PROVIDER": 0,
        "LOCAL_BASELINE": 5
       },
       "per_class": {
        "HUMAN_COLLABORATOR": {
         "ballots": 1,
         "scores": {
          "rehearsal-empty": 4.0,
          "rehearsal-strong": 21.0,
          "rehearsal-weak": 9.0
         },
         "ranking": [
          "rehearsal-strong",
          "rehearsal-weak",
          "rehearsal-empty"
         ]
        },
        "MODEL_PROVIDER": {
         "ballots": 0,
         "scores": {},
         "ranking": []
        },
        "LOCAL_BASELINE": {
         "ballots": 5,
         "scores": {
          "rehearsal-strong": 25.0,
          "rehearsal-weak": 8.538,
          "rehearsal-empty": 1.0
         },
         "ranking": [
          "rehearsal-strong",
          "rehearsal-weak",
          "rehearsal-empty"
         ]
        }
       },
       "classes_present": [
        "HUMAN_COLLABORATOR",
        "LOCAL_BASELINE"
       ],
       "ranked_outcome": [
        "rehearsal-strong",
        "rehearsal-weak",
        "rehearsal-empty"
       ]
      }
     }
    },
    {
     "event_key": "795a845f4f2a362fed99fb907e6b11e1fdcb3c94f263933db48b1b60e75fce23",
     "comment_id": 6478760068,
     "created_at": "2026-10-28T19:37:59Z",
     "marker": "<!-- delphi-generation-calibration v1 -->",
     "class": "machine-state",
     "headline": "<!-- n5-emit:delphi-cycle/rehearsal:calibration -->",
     "payload": {
      "type": "delphi-generation-calibration",
      "pass_id": "rehearsal",
      "calibration": {
       "schema": "oracle-method-calibration/v1",
       "evidence_set_sha256": "dde5aac5d62b8e6f6a946564908ee055b3e19cc488c61aeee62015013768d9ac",
       "candidates": {
        "HUMAN_COLLABORATOR": {
         "rehearsal-strong": {
          "expected_rank": 1,
          "actual_rank": 1,
          "rank_delta": 0,
          "expected_score": 20.0,
          "actual_score": 21.0,
          "score_delta": 1.0,
          "within_tolerance": true,
          "moved_on_evidence": [
           "full test pass in the implementation round"
          ]
         },
         "rehearsal-weak": {
          "expected_rank": 2,
          "actual_rank": 2,
          "rank_delta": 0,
          "expected_score": 12.0,
          "actual_score": 9.0,
          "score_delta": -3.0,
          "within_tolerance": false,
          "moved_on_evidence": [
           "3 failing test(s) in the implementation round"
          ]
         },
         "rehearsal-empty": {
          "expected_rank": 3,
          "actual_rank": 3,
          "rank_delta": 0,
          "expected_score": 6.0,
          "actual_score": 4.0,
          "score_delta": -2.0,
          "within_tolerance": true,
          "moved_on_evidence": [
           "2 failing test(s) in the implementation round"
          ]
         }
        },
        "LOCAL_BASELINE": {
         "rehearsal-strong": {
          "expected_rank": 1,
          "actual_rank": 1,
          "rank_delta": 0,
          "expected_score": 24.231,
          "actual_score": 25.0,
          "score_delta": 0.769,
          "within_tolerance": true,
          "moved_on_evidence": [
           "full test pass in the implementation round"
          ]
         },
         "rehearsal-weak": {
          "expected_rank": 2,
          "actual_rank": 2,
          "rank_delta": 0,
          "expected_score": 10.846,
          "actual_score": 8.538,
          "score_delta": -2.308,
          "within_tolerance": false,
          "moved_on_evidence": [
           "3 failing test(s) in the implementation round"
          ]
         },
         "rehearsal-empty": {
          "expected_rank": 3,
          "actual_rank": 3,
          "rank_delta": 0,
          "expected_score": 4.038,
          "actual_score": 1.0,
          "score_delta": -3.038,
          "within_tolerance": false,
          "moved_on_evidence": [
           "2 failing test(s) in the implementation round"
          ]
         }
        }
       }
      }
     }
    }
   ],
   "current": null,
   "excluded_noise": 0
  }
 ],
 "living_records": [
  {
   "id": "temporal-selfhost-status",
   "title": "Temporal self-host status (living record)",
   "issue": 2028,
   "kind": "living-body",
   "semantics": "not append-only at the source; the feed + the Neon mirror make versions append-only by keying on the body hash; ASSIGNED MARKER (Delphi lane recommendation, 2026-10-28): future snapshot comments on living-record issues carry '<!-- delphi-living v1 -->' so collectors can separate them from third-party noise; the #2028 body pattern is unchanged until its writer adopts it",
   "state_rule": "the issue BODY is the current state (edited in place by the keepalive job); version key = sha256(body) \u2014 a changed hash is a new version of the record",
   "marker": null,
   "assigned_marker": "<!-- delphi-living v1 -->",
   "body_marker": "<!-- delphi-living v1 -->",
   "version_key": "e75b28161de9481faecd5533269e7d6e3657f6ff5cc50a85437f4ffda67eda07",
   "snapshot_at": "2026-10-28T18:30:11Z",
   "updated_at": "2026-10-28T20:05:57Z",
   "body": "<!-- delphi-living v1 -->\n[MUSEai]@{role:{delphi-lane}} \u2014 **Temporal self-host status** (living record; refreshed by the keepalive job on every repair + daily).\n\n**Snapshot 2026-10-28T18:30:11Z**\n\n| Item | State |\n|---|---|\n| Units | temporal-selfhost + temporal-relay: `active / active` |\n| API | localhost:7233 answers (gRPC); Web UI localhost:8233 \u2192 HTTP 200 |\n| Relay | 0.0.0.0:7234 \u2192 127.0.0.1:7233 (CLI via :7234 answers) |\n| DB | ~/workspace/temporal-selfhost/temporal.db \u2014 729088 bytes, durable disk |\n| Backups | temporal-20261028.db (daily, integrity-checked, newest 7) |\n| Keepalive | every 15 min \u2014 reinstalls units after VM replacement (`/etc` is ephemeral), silent when healthy |\n\n**Repair this run:** both units were `not-found` again (VM replacement had wiped /etc a second time today; prior repair 2026-10-28T16:28:08Z); `install.sh` reinstalled + enabled them, both active since 2026-10-28T18:28:44Z, CLI answers on :7233 and :7234. No daily snapshot taken \u2014 temporal-20261028.db already exists (integrity re-verified `ok` this run).\n\n**Workflows on the server**\n\n```\nCompleted  kill-resume-unit-1793192868  DurableUnitWorkflow  5 hours ago\n  Completed  kill-resume-unit-1793175195  DurableUnitWorkflow  10 hours ago\n  Completed  kill-resume-unit-1793175148  DurableUnitWorkflow  10 hours ago\n```\n\nDesign + operator record: docs/ops/TEMPORAL-SELF-HOST.md (PR #1989, doc corr. PR #2014). Owner ruling 2026-10-28: Required infrastructure is reviewable via GitHub surfaces \u2014 this issue is that surface for the Temporal self-host.\n"
  },
  {
   "id": "results-board",
   "title": "Delphi results board",
   "issue": 1474,
   "kind": "living-body",
   "semantics": "DERIVED board regenerated by delphi-gate into the issue body (generated-at stamp in body); ledger of record = newest '<!-- delphi-ledger v1 -->' comment per RFP issue \u2014 the board itself is a render, never a source",
   "state_rule": "the issue BODY is the current board (body starts with the delphi-board marker); version key = sha256(body)",
   "marker": "<!-- delphi-board v1 -->",
   "assigned_marker": null,
   "body_marker": "<!-- delphi-board v1 -->",
   "version_key": "3b9d7e641ad6852d382b69c88e99eeb3f10d8868a78e2aeee36426ced592e5b0",
   "snapshot_at": null,
   "updated_at": "2026-10-28T21:43:07Z",
   "body": "<!-- delphi-board v1 -->\nGenerated by delphi-gate at 2026-10-28 21:43 UTC. Ledger of record: the newest `<!-- delphi-ledger v1 -->` comment on each RFP.\n\n| RFP | Surface | Effective /25 | Award | Band | Recheck |\n|---|---|---|---|---|---|\n| #1424 | `github.native_ledger` | 18.55 | shadow | High | - |\n| #1423 | `turso.free` | 16.54 | shadow | High | - |\n| #1420 | `supabase.free` | 14.62 | parked | Medium | 2026-11-11T00:20Z |\n| #1421 | `cloudflare.d1_queues` | 14.62 | parked | Medium | 2026-11-11T00:20Z |\n| #1416 | `neon.data_api` | 12.92 | parked | Medium | 2026-11-11T00:20Z |\n| #1488 | `tribute-lane` | 12.69 | parked | Medium | 2026-11-11T00:21Z |\n| #1425 | `gemini.free` | 12.23 | parked | Medium | 2026-11-11T01:17Z |\n| #1426 | `openrouter.free` | 12.23 | parked | Medium | 2026-11-11T00:21Z |\n| #1428 | `grafana.cloud_free` | 12.0 | parked | Medium | 2026-11-11T00:21Z |\n| #1422 | `upstash.free` | 11.54 | parked | Medium | 2026-11-11T00:21Z |\n| #1419 | `vercel.hobby` | 10.81 | parked | Medium | 2026-11-11T00:20Z |\n| #1427 | `g4f.vendors` | 9.23 | parked | Medium | 2026-11-11T14:43Z |\n| #1567 | `issue-1567` | 9.12 | parked | Medium | 2026-11-11T00:21Z |\n| #1571 | `issue-1571` | 9.12 | parked | Medium | 2026-11-11T00:21Z |\n| #1572 | `issue-1572` | 9.12 | parked | Medium | 2026-11-11T00:21Z |\n| #1418 | `render.free` | 8.77 | parked | Backlog | 2026-11-27T00:20Z |\n| #1591 | `fly.free_tier` | 8.54 | parked | Backlog | 2026-11-27T00:21Z |\n| #1415 | `neon.realtime` | 7.15 | parked | Backlog | 2026-11-27T00:20Z |\n| #1417 | `platform201.solo` | 6.69 | parked | Backlog | 2026-11-27T07:05Z |\n| #1959 | `doe.criteria-loop` | 6.69 | parked | Backlog | 2026-11-27T04:38Z |\n| #1963 | `delphi.method-self-application` | 6.69 | parked | Backlog | 2026-11-27T04:38Z |\n| #1975 | `markov.trellis-lab` | 6.69 | parked | Backlog | 2026-11-27T07:06Z |\n| #1976 | `bayesian.routing` | 6.69 | parked | Backlog | 2026-11-27T07:06Z |\n| #1977 | `kahn.dag` | 6.69 | parked | Backlog | 2026-11-27T07:06Z |\n| #1978 | `gantt.dependency-phases` | 6.69 | parked | Backlog | 2026-11-27T07:06Z |\n| #1430 | `manus.credits` | 4.62 | parked | Backlog | 2026-11-27T00:21Z |\n| #1431 | `polsia.credits` | 4.62 | parked | Backlog | 2026-11-27T00:21Z |\n| #1429 | `cellcog.credits` | 4.31 | parked | Backlog | 2026-11-27T00:21Z |\n\n28 open RFPs \u00b7 2 shadow \u00b7 26 parked \u00b7 0 pending. Rubric-only panel (MSM-018); awards are advisory.\n\n### Radar: 133 surfaces with no RFP yet\nFile one with the Delphi Oracle RFP issue form to put a surface through the gate.\n\n| Surface | Lane | Seen in | Source |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| `otel-semantic-conventions` | agent-observability | foresight | [link](https://github.com/open-telemetry/semantic-conventions) |\n| `aion.free_tokens` | model | quota-registry | [link](https://api.aionlabs.ai/docs/rate-limits/) |\n| `aws.account_credits` | ops | quota-registry | [link](https://aws.amazon.com/free/) |\n| `aws.dynamodb_storage` | data | quota-registry | [link](https://aws.amazon.com/free/) |\n| `aws.lambda_compute` | deploy | quota-registry | [link](https://aws.amazon.com/lambda/pricing/) |\n| `aws.lambda_requests` | deploy | quota-registry | [link](https://aws.amazon.com/lambda/pricing/) |\n| `azure.account_credit` | ops | quota-registry | [link](https://azure.microsoft.com/en-us/pricing/offers/ms-azr-0044p) |\n| `azure.functions_executions` | deploy | quota-registry | [link](https://azure.microsoft.com/en-us/pricing/offers/ms-azr-0044p) |\n| `cerebras.free_tokens` | model | quota-registry | [link](https://inference-docs.cerebras.ai/support/rate-limits) |\n| `cloudflare.d1_rows_read` | data | quota-registry | [link](https://developers.cloudflare.com/d1/platform/pricing/) |\n| `cloudflare.d1_rows_written` | data | quota-registry | [link](https://developers.cloudflare.com/d1/platform/pricing/) |\n| `cloudflare.d1_storage` | data | quota-registry | [link](https://developers.cloudflare.com/d1/platform/pricing/) |\n| `cloudflare.kv_writes` | data | quota-registry | [link](https://developers.cloudflare.com/kv/platform/pricing/) |\n| `cloudflare.queues_ops` | data | quota-registry | [link](https://developers.cloudflare.com/d1/platform/pricing/) |\n| `cloudflare.r2_storage` | data | quota-registry | [link](https://developers.cloudflare.com/r2/pricing/) |\n| `cloudflare.workers_ai` | model | quota-registry | [link](https://developers.cloudflare.com/workers-ai/platform/pricing/) |\n| `cloudflare.workers_requests` | deploy | quota-registry | [link](https://developers.cloudflare.com/workers/platform/pricing/) |\n| `cohere.trial_calls` | model | quota-registry | [link](https://docs.cohere.com/docs/rate-limits) |\n| `deno.deploy_requests` | deploy | quota-registry | [link](https://deno.com/deploy/pricing) |\n| `digitalocean.app_platform_static` | deploy | quota-registry | [link](https://www.digitalocean.com/pricing/app-platform) |\n| `digitalocean.trial_credit` | ops | quota-registry | [link](https://www.digitalocean.com/pricing/app-platform) |\n| `felo.api_credits` | model | quota-registry | [link](https://openapi.felo.ai/pricing) |\n| `g4f.agenttools` | model | quota-registry | [link](https://api.toolsforagents.tools/site/index.html) |\n| `g4f.airforce` | model | quota-registry | [link](https://api.airforce/docs/quickstart/) |\n| `g4f.antigravity` | model | quota-registry | [link](https://antigravity.google/docs/plans) |\n| `g4f.arena` | model | quota-registry | [link](https://arena.ai/faq) |\n| `g4f.bingcreateimages` | model | quota-registry | [link](https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-365/microsoft-designer) |\n| `g4f.blackboxpro` | model | quota-registry | [link](https://www.blackbox.ai/pricing) |\n| `g4f.blackforestlabs_flux1dev` | model | quota-registry | [link](https://huggingface.co/docs/hub/en/spaces-zerogpu) |\n| `g4f.blackforestlabs_flux1kontextdev` | model | quota-registry | [link](https://huggingface.co/docs/hub/en/spaces-zerogpu) |\n| `g4f.bravesearch` | model | quota-registry | [link](https://brave.com/ai/) |\n| `g4f.cachedsearch` | model | quota-registry | [link](https://g4f.dev) |\n| `g4f.cerebras` | model | quota-registry | [link](https://inference-docs.cerebras.ai/support/rate-limits) |\n| `g4f.chatgpt` | model | quota-registry | [link](https://help.openai.com/en/articles/9275245-chatgpt-free-tier-faq) |\n| `g4f.claude` | model | quota-registry | [link](https://support.claude.com/en/articles/8114491-get-started-with-claude) |\n| `g4f.cloudflare` | model | quota-registry | [link](https://developers.cloudflare.com/workers-ai/platform/pricing/) |\n| `g4f.cohereforai_c4ai_command` | model | quota-registry | [link](https://coherelabs-c4ai-command.hf.space) |\n| `g4f.copilot` | model | quota-registry | [link](https://copilot.com) |\n| `g4f.copilotapp` | model | quota-registry | [link](https://play.google.com/store/apps/details/Microsoft_Copilot?id=com.microsoft.copilot&hl=en_IE) |\n| `g4f.deepinfra` | model | quota-registry | [link](https://deepinfra.com/blog/compare-models) |\n| \u2026 | | | 93 more |"
  }
 ],
 "invariants": {
  "append_only": "corrections are NEW events naming what they supersede, never edits (one graded step once consumed by a misdirected write was deliberately NOT replayed \u2014 bounded-loss lesson)",
  "idempotency": "keys on every ingest: tribute signals keyed by thread URL, gate dedupe sha256(key|outcome); mirror/feed key sha256(ledger_id|comment_id)",
  "source_classes": [
   "HUMAN_COLLABORATOR",
   "MODEL_PROVIDER",
   "LOCAL_BASELINE"
  ],
  "source_classes_rule": "never collapsed in any store, feed or render; DRIVER_SYNTHESIS is not a ballot",
  "honest_negatives": "none_validated_yet / none_yet and similar are findings recorded as data, never coerced to null or dropped",
  "resolution": "ledgers resolved by exact issue TITLE at registration (label-order resolution misdirected state to #1567/#1784 once; fixed PR #1833); this registry pins the resolved numbers"
 },
 "summary": {
  "events": 18,
  "excluded_noise": 3
 }
}
